Thursday, February 17, 2011

It’s Business, It’s Not Personal…or is it?

“I am in earnest--I will not equivocate--I will not excuse--I will not retreat a single inch and I will be heard.”   ~ William Lloyd Garrison ~

I took a political science course in college and one of the things my professor told me was that my determination will take me places.  When it comes to justice vs. injustice, I don’t back away easily.  I’m tenacious and yes, very determined.  I’ve always had a weakness for the underdog.  My son is an underdog.  I think children in special education are underdogs especially in the public school system.

When parents challenge the opinions of the school on the appropriate approach to educating their child, it is not personal.  It is not personal to go after the institution responsible for making important decisions that ultimately shape our children.  Parents are very important members of the IEP team.   Their opinions, thoughts and concerns need to be heard and taken seriously.  It is all too often that school districts bully parents into submission because they don’t want to add resources.  Districts akin to warlords have no mercy for the ignorance of parent knowledge of the special education school system.  In fact, they feed on it like piranha wearing us down with every bite.  It is unacceptable that only the most determined, savvy parent with the deepest pockets and resources are able to get an appropriate educational prescription for their child.  I am determined but do not have deep pockets.  My financial resources are limited.  I don’t have a great deal of disposable income.  My husband and I make financial sacrifices to have our child tested appropriately and thoroughly.  In effect, it is only personal for us because we care about the welfare of our child. 

It has taken three years to reach the place where I am today challenging how my child will be taught and how his needs will be met.  Aren is in 3rd grade and is no better equipped to enter the 4th grade than he was entering the 2nd and 3rd grades.  He is behind and it is unacceptable.  The special education teacher decided long ago, my son wouldn’t make the grade.  In my mind, she gave up on him before he left the gate.  This is the same special education teacher he has had since kindergarten.

There has been a shift in attitude and I have a theory about this which I’ll get to later in this post.  Yesterday at a parent-teacher conference, the special education and the general education teachers told me and my husband they don’t know what to do.  It is the first time ever we heard these words.  They also said (for the first time), presently Aren is not well equipped to take the upcoming state exam.  I only voiced this concern at the end of 1st grade and it fell on deaf ears.  Keep in mind these are the same people who in so many ways suggested they know what my child needs.  Previously, they were only too quick to dismiss our concerns and compare our child to non-disable children his age as age appropriate behaviors.  We  told them, we need to consider other placements for Aren.  We have been telling them this since the end of 1st grade. 

Our dream and goal for Aren is to take regents exams and graduate H.S. with a general education diploma not an I.E.P. diploma.  In  order for that to happen, Aren requires more resources.  It can happen, in an appropriate setting that has the resources to meet Aren’s individual needs.  Aren is high functioning so finding a suitable placement is a challenge.  But I am determined.  I will not give up trying.  The district needs to be willing and allow us to have referrals to other schools.  Or, they need to change their approach in how they’re educating Aren.  These are the only options and the former is the more desirable because the current classroom setting is too large with a total population of 20 students.  It is too large for Aren.  Further, he requires additional assistance.  Aren needs a person to help him stay on task because he is easily distracted due to ADD.  My husband and I are not quick to medicate our son.  This is the quick fix and ultimately we don’t know how that will play out in his developing body.  I’m not eager to put my child on a stimulate.  All I hear from the districts are suggestions that would make their lives easier.  Their needs are above my son.  I must sacrifice again and again and again, plus gamble on my son’s health.  This is my opinion and it matters.  It matters because Aren is my son and my husband and I are here for the duration while teachers are transient figures in my child’s life.  However, understand transient doesn’t mean less of an impact for better or worse on our children only temporary.  In this regard, I have a much longer view and investment on my son’s life and the path I’m trying to map out for him.

To no avail and no small measure, I’ve been trying to work out an education plan with the district.  I’ve taken all the appropriate steps by making appeal after appeal to get our concerns resolved for Aren’s sake.  They have dragged things out, dismissed our concerns and in every manner of speaking have suggested they know what’s best for my son – not me or the professionals at the NYU Child Study Center.   They made claims that they could meet my son’s needs yet he is not working at grade level.  They threw stumbling blocks in our path to getting an appropriate education and now the general education teacher is wondering why Aren is less attentive.  He has always had attention issues.  The bigger problem is that Aren is much more aware and is measuring his success against his peers.  Aren doesn’t want to appear “slow” so he rushes through his work and leaves a trail of mistakes.  He fools around in class and needs constant reminders to attend to the work.   It is arrogance and the need to consider the bottom line that drives their position and decisions that are detrimental to my son’s education.   Their decisions are not based on the law or the evidence in front of their eyes.  This attitude is not good for any child with special educational needs.

After months of consultation with an attorney, a due process complaint was filed with the district this past Tuesday.  In this very small school district, we got the idea the word spread very quickly.  We think this is the reason for the attitude shift we met up with yesterday.   In previous meetings, the reception was icy and very resistant to our concerns and suggestions for Aren.  Parents who heavily advocate for their children are often not met with a “red carpet”.  We are movers and shakers and districts tend to not like it very much.  In the words of the comedian, Lewis Black, “it makes them cry”.  If we only could have worked out our differences two years ago, I don’t think I would be writing this blog.  Things would have been a lot different.  Reaching this point of filing a due processing complaint is not as a result of my lack of trying to arrive at a mutually agreeable education plan for Aren.  It was filed because the district refused to meet us half way.  I didn’t want this, in fact, I tried to avoid it.  I don’t want an adversarial relationship with the district but I will not roll over and show my belly either!  My son has rights under the law.  All persons with disabilities have rights under the law.  If a school district refuses to see to reason, what other recourse outside of directly pulling our child out of school have?  Pulling my child out isn’t an option.  The burden shouldn’t fall on the parents shoulders.  We have already been through enough.  School districts need to step up to the plate and do the right thing – appropriately educate our children and be willing to try different things to meet the individual educational needs of each child. 


  1. Do you think the State considering reducing the amount of aid to schools for private special Ed placements is going to be a big concern? The state wants to shift the burden to the local taxpayers and that scares me.

  2. All of our children have the privilege and benefit of attending public school because of tax dollars. In other countries, parents must pay for their children to attend school. Unfortunately, education is one of the areas that gets hit the hardest during economic downturns. And, in this current adminstration, our government is looking at cutting programs that aid the neediest of it's citizens. The priorities are completely warped, in my opinion.

    Schools receive reveneue through home owners property and school taxes. Right now, the housing market is depressed and as a result property value has gone down. This effects the amount of tax dollars paid by home owners. In this present environment it translates to less dollars by way of taxes from home owners. It's a domino effect. With that being said, I don't think you should fear higher taxes but programs being cut due to not enough.

    The laws are on the books that every child is entitled to a free and appropriate education whether it be in publc or private schools. By law, the state and school districts are obligated to provide it.

    I think we should be more concerned that not enough money is funneled into education and programs are being are limited or cut all together.


Thanks for sharing your thoughts and comments on this blog.